The book of Job is difficult, like Shakespeare is difficult: It’s old, it’s a play, and it’s poetry. But drink deeply from its fountain, and the refreshment will astonish you.
Literary Markers
There is a clear shift from narrative (chapters 1-2) to poetry (chapters 3-41) and back again (chapter 42). Therefore the lengthy poetic speeches serve as the book’s body, with the narratives playing the role of prologue and epilogue.
The poetic units of thought are clearly marked by narrative statements regarding who is speaking. Make a simple list of the order of speeches, and a shape will emerge:
- Narrative prologue: Job 1:1-2:13
- Job – Job 3:1
- Eliphaz – Job 4:1
- Job – Job 6:1
- Bildad – Job 8:1
- Job – Job 9:1
- Zophar – Job 11:1
- Job – Job 12:1
- Eliphaz – Job 15:1
- Job – Job 16:1
- Bildad – Job 18:1
- Job – Job 19:1
- Zophar – Job 20:1
- Job – Job 21:1
- Eliphaz – Job 22:1
- Job – Job 23:1
- Bildad – Job 25:1
- Job – Job 26:1
- Job – Job 27:1
- Job – Job 29:1
- Elihu – Job 32:6
- Elihu – Job 34:1
- Elihu – Job 35:1
- Elihu – Job 36:1
- Yahweh – Job 38:1
- Yahweh – Job 40:1
- Job – Job 40:3
- Yahweh – Job 40:6
- Job – Job 42:1
- Narrative epilogue – Job 42:7-17
So a cursory glance at the list shows us that Job interacts with three friends: Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar. Then Job monologues on his own. Then a fourth friend, Elihu, monologues. Then Yahweh interacts with Job.
Let’s walk through these sections.
The Setup
The thing that gets Job into this mess is that he fears God and turns away from evil (Job 1:1). For that reason, when Satan goes looking for trouble in all the wrong places, God draws a bull’s-eye on his main man (Job 1:7-8, 2:2-3). Make no mistake: God draws Satan’s attention to Job, because Job fears God. If that fact doesn’t terrify you, I don’t know what will.
Consider what’s at stake here. Both the narrator (once) and God (twice) unequivocally assert Job’s fear of God (Job 1:1, 8; 2:3). And this fear is the very thing Satan calls into question: “Does Job fear God for no reason?” (Job 1:9). Satan places his bet: “Job doesn’t really fear God; he just loves the nice things God gives him. Take those things away, and his ‘fear of God’ will melt into face-to-face cursing of God” (paraphrase of Job 1:10-11, 2:4-5). God goes all in: “Game on” (Job 1:12, 2:6).
The narrator’s key question is this: Will Job still fear God when he loses everything he loves?
Job’s Fear
Job takes up his lament in chapter 3 with his own key question: Why is this happening to me? He knows nothing of God’s bet with Satan. He has no explanation for his loss, his bereavement, or his pain. He curses the day of his birth and the night of his conception (Job 3:1-7). He even asks others to join him in cursing that day and that night (Job 3:8).
But when he turns to consider God, he has no curse. He has only questions filled with dread (Job 3:20-26).
Dialogue with Three Friends
Eliphaz, Bildad, and Zophar then speak in turn, for three cycles, and Job responds to every one of their speeches. Eliphaz and Bildad both speak three times, but Zophar does not speak in the third cycle and so gives only two speeches.
It is clear that the three friends believe Job to be suffering because he must have some secret sin of which he has not yet repented (Job 4:7, 8:3-7, 11:4-6, etc.). It is likewise clear that Job believes himself to be innocent of sin (Job 6:10, 9:21-22, 13:18, etc.).
But whether Job sinned or not is only on the surface of the debate. The subsurface debate—and the reason for so many speeches—is the question of how to respond to suffering. In particular: What does it mean to fear the Lord in your suffering? The three friends believe that if Job really feared God, he would confess his secret sins (Job 4:6-7, 15:4, etc.). And Job believes that if they really feared God, they wouldn’t say such stupid things (Job 6:14, 12:2-6, etc.). Job argues time and again that fearing God means holding fast to him even when it looks and feels as though he has turned against you (Job 13:15-16).
We should also see that Job’s thinking changes, while the friends’ thinking doesn’t. Compare the friends’ first speech (Job 4:17) with their last speech (Job 25:4), and you’ll hear the wheels spinning and the broken record player turning and turning and turning and turning. Yet Job begins in league with them (Job 4:2-5), moves to a dark place (Job 7:7-8), and ends in a very different, yet still dark, place, knowing full well that his God will still see him when he dies (Job 26:5-6).
How does Job get from point A (God won’t see me) to point B (God will see me)? In chapter 14, Job realizes that his suffering would have a purpose if he could be resurrected; but he quickly discards that hope. In chapter 16, he discovers that his suffering would have a purpose if he had a mediator; but he quickly discards that hope as well. Then in chapter 19, he puts the two hopes together—envisioning a resurrected mediator—and he absolutely freaks out. In the next few speeches he discards even that hope as being too good to be true, yet the possibility of it changes him forever.
Job’s Closing Arguments
Job completes his dialogue with these friends in chapter 27, where he draws three conclusions:
- I have not sinned – Job 27:2-6
- My friends have become my enemies – Job 27:7-12
- Wicked men (like my enemies) deserve God’s devastating judgment – Job 27:13-23
Chapter 28 stands apart, with a very different tone and style than any other speech in the book. This poem’s “voice” is more like that of the playwright than that of any characters in the play. This chapter celebrates the fact that humanity will never find God’s wisdom through their own devices. Only by fearing the Lord can any person be able to find wisdom.
Job’s last major speech is directed at God, not the three friends, and makes three arguments:
- My best days are lost and gone – Job 29
- My worst days have come upon me – Job 30
- I dare God to speak up and challenge my innocence – Job 31
One More Friend
A new character named Elihu shows up quite suddenly in Job 32:2, and interpreters have widely diverging opinions on whether we ought to affirm Elihu’s speeches (like God’s) or reject them (like the other three friends). The most viewed post in the history of this blog takes up this matter, so I direct your attention there for a deeper dive. But here is a summary of the evidence:
- Elihu’s argument is different. Where they argued, “Before Job began suffering, he must have sinned,” Elihu argues, “Since Job began suffering, he has sinned.” He doesn’t focus on the cause of Job’s suffering, but the response to it.
- Elihu brings not platitudes, but concrete evidence of sin on Job’s part (Job 33:8-11, 33:13, 34:5-6, 35:2-3, 36:23).
- Elihu speaks more times (4) than any of the other friends. Job never issues a rebuttal, despite Elihu inviting him to do so (Job 33:32-33).
- Elihu distances himself and his arguments from the other three (Job 32:3, 11-18). He clearly believes he is in a different category than they are.
Elihu’s four speeches ring with incredible truth desperately needed by any innocent sufferer:
- God has not been silent; he speaks through your pain (Job 32-33).
- God is not unjust; he will eventually strike the wicked (Job 34).
- Righteous living is not pointless, though we are insignificant next to God (Job 35).
- You’re in no place to criticize God; remember to fear him (Job 36-37).
The Whirlwind
Just as Elihu completes his arguments, Yahweh shows up in a whirlwind to affirm them.
In his first speech (and the tag to it in Job 40:1), Yahweh employs the natural creation to show how Job has acted as a faultfinder. In his second speech, Yahweh employs the supernatural creation to show how Job has misplaced his fear and ought to recenter it on his God.
Narrative Epilogue
In the closing narrative, Yahweh sets things straight between Job and the first three friends. Though he called Job to repent of his arrogance (Job 42:6), he simultaneously commends Job’s faith in holding fast to Yahweh and his righteousness in judgment (Job 42:7).
And then Yahweh does something no other god of any other nation would ever do: He puts himself in the place of a thief, and he returns twofold restitution to Job for all he lost. A God of such grace cannot ever be manipulated or controlled. May we all learn to fear the one who sent his own son to die like a criminal, then resurrected him as mediator of a new covenant, for the salvation of the world.
If this God would allow the innocent Job (and Jesus) to be treated as though he were guilty, perhaps he can also make it so the guilty (like us) could be treated as though we were innocent (2 Cor 5:21).
Conclusion
This book’s main idea is not so much about suffering in itself, but about how to respond to suffering in the fear of the Lord.
Interpretive Outline
- Narrative Prologue: One who fears God chosen to suffer – Job 1-2
- Act I: Cursing one’s life while still fearing God – Job 3
- Act II: Why we must respond to suffering in fear of God – Job 4-26
- Act III: Informed judgment of those who refuse to fear God — Job 27
- Act IV: The beginning of wisdom is the fear of God – Job 28
- Act V: Uninformed judgment of him who needs to deepen in the fear of God – Job 29-31
- Act III: Informed judgment of those who refuse to fear God — Job 27
- Act VI: How to respond to suffering in fear of God – Job 32-37
- Act II: Why we must respond to suffering in fear of God – Job 4-26
- Act VII: Reaching new heights in the fear of God – Job 38:1-42:6
- Act I: Cursing one’s life while still fearing God – Job 3
- Narrative Epilogue: Our dangerous Deity puts the fear of God in people, in part by taking the blame for their suffering – Job 42:7-17
For more interpretive walkthroughs of books of the Bible, click here.
Leave a Reply